FISHINGFIX
← The Journal
· The FishingFix Team

Spring Trout Fishing by Water Temperature: Nymphs, Hatches and Spinners

Spring trout fishing is mostly a question of water temperature. Early in the season, snowmelt and cold rain keep streams in the 30s and low 40s °F and trout are sluggish; by late spring the water is in the 50s and trout are feeding hard on insect hatches and chasing lures. The tactics that work change with it. This guide goes through the stages, using a stream thermometer as the guide, and covers the flows and wading safety that spring water demands. The techniques apply to trout streams across the northern US, including New York's, where this article started.

Measure the water, not the air

Air temperature on a sunny spring afternoon says little about a stream fed by snowmelt. A cheap stream thermometer, held in the current for a minute, tells you which of the stages below you are in. Our Weather Fishing Planner takes water temperature as one of its five inputs and scores it in bands: 55 to 75 °F scores 90 out of 100 for temperature, 45 up to 55 °F and above 75 up to 85 °F score 65, and anything colder or warmer scores 40. Holding the other inputs steady (steady pressure, 8 mph wind, partly cloudy, an ordinary moon), here is how the overall score moves through spring:

WaterTemperature sub-scoreOverall scoreRating
36 °F4065Good
40 °F4065Good
44 °F4065Good
45 °F6570Good
50 °F6570Good
54 °F6570Good
55 °F9075Excellent
62 °F9075Excellent
70 °F9075Excellent
75 °F9075Excellent
76 °F6570Good

The planner's bands are broad and general to all freshwater fish; trout are a cold-water species and often feed well in the high 40s and low 50s, below the planner's best band. Treat the table as a description of how the planner weighs temperature, and the stages below as the trout-specific detail.

Cold water: 35 to 45 °F

When water temperatures are low, in the mid 30s to the low 40s, trout hold in deeper, slower water and feed little and slowly. To reach them, fish slow drifts close to the bottom.

  • Weighted nymphs drifted along the bottom through deep runs and pools, or a streamer that imitates natural food such as sculpins or crayfish, fished slowly.
  • Bait, where it is allowed: worms or salted minnows drifted through deep holes. Our Bait Selector suggests worms, salmon eggs and mealworms for trout, with the tip “Drift bait naturally with the current and keep your line light and unweighted.” Many trout waters restrict bait or require artificial lures and flies only, so read the rules for the water first.
  • The dry-dropper rig shows whether trout are feeding higher in the water: a buoyant dry fly with a small sinking nymph tied on a short tippet off the bend of its hook. Trout can take either, and the dry fly works as a strike indicator for the nymph.

Follow the hatches

As spring goes on, mayflies, caddisflies and stoneflies hatch in large numbers, and trout feed heavily on these easy meals. Knowing when and where hatches happen lets you match the insect with the right fly. Hatch charts for many rivers are published online, and a local fly shop will know what is hatching this week.

Spin anglers can use hatches too. They may not imitate the insects directly, but small lures such as soft grubs and tiny jigs suit fish that are focused on small food. When using baitfish imitations at this time of year, think small; large lures are often ignored.

Warmer water: 50 °F and up

Once the water reaches about 50 °F, spinners become a good way to cover water and find active fish. The selector's trout lures are an inline spinner, small spoon and soft-plastic trout dough. With an inline spinner:

  • Use a good-quality snap swivel to stop the spinning blade twisting the line.
  • Cast across the stream at about 45 degrees downstream and let the spinner swing slowly across on a tight line, reeling just fast enough to keep the blade turning.
  • Make a few casts in each spot, then move on. Covering water finds the active fish.

Keep the line light: our Fishing Line Calculator starts trout at 6 lb, and in small clear streams lighter still.

Measuring a spring trout

Spring trout, especially fish stocked over the winter or wild fish after a lean season, are often thin for their length, which is exactly when a length-only weight estimate goes wrong. A 16 inch trout measured with an 8 inch girth comes out at 1.28 lb on our Fish Weight Calculator. Enter the length alone and it gives 2.56 lb, twice as much, and flags the figure as rough because there is no published length-only rule for trout. If you want a weight for the log, take the girth with a soft tape while the fish is in the net, then release it with wet hands and as little time out of the cold water as possible. Many spring trout waters are catch and release only, or have their own size limits; check before you keep one.

Walk away from the crowds

Popular access points get crowded in spring, especially on opening day and near stocking points. Anglers willing to walk further from the parking area are often rewarded with a better experience. Most state agencies publish maps of public fishing access and stocked waters; in New York, the DEC's online maps and HuntFishNY app show access points across the state.

Read the flows before you go

Big spring storms can “blow out” a trout stream, raising the flow and muddying the water so it is hard to fish and dangerous to wade. Check the US Geological Survey's real-time stream gauges before heading out. Over a few trips, note the flow at which your stream fishes well, and the flow above which it is too high to wade. A rising gauge on the morning of a trip is a reason to change plans.

Wading safely in cold, high water

  • Cold water is the main danger in spring. A fall into snowmelt can cause cold-water shock, an involuntary gasp and rapid breathing that makes it hard to swim. Wear a wading belt cinched tight over waders, and consider an inflatable life jacket on big or fast rivers. Always wear a life jacket in a boat or kayak.
  • Use a wading staff and felt or studded soles, shuffle rather than stride, and face upstream when crossing.
  • Do not wade above your knees in fast water. Strong current can take your feet from under you in surprisingly shallow water.
  • Watch the water level below dams, where releases can raise it quickly.
  • Do not fish alone in remote or risky spots, and tell someone your plan.
  • Leave the water if you hear thunder. Spring storms build fast, and graphite rods conduct electricity.

Conclusion

Spring trout fishing rewards anglers who watch the thermometer and the flow gauge as closely as the water. Fish slow and deep in cold water, follow the hatches as it warms, switch to spinners as it passes 50 °F, and walk a little further than everyone else. Check the trout season dates and special regulations for each water with the state agency before you go.

Get new guides by emailOccasional emails. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.