How Windy Is Too Windy to Fish? Wind, Small Boats and Lightning
A light breeze is one of the best things that can happen to a fishing day. It ruffles the surface, cuts the light, pushes bait against a windward shore and hides you from the fish. A strong wind is one of the worst: it makes casting and boat control hard, turns open water rough, and on the coast changes the tide. Somewhere between the two is the point where you should not be out at all. This guide explains how our Weather Fishing Planner scores wind, where it stops rating a day as fishable, and the conditions that matter more than any score.
How the planner scores wind
Wind is 20% of the planner's overall score. It uses three bands: up to 10 mph scores best, over 10 and up to 18 mph scores less, and anything over 18 mph scores lowest. On top of that, any wind over 18 mph caps the whole rating at Poor, whatever the other inputs say.
Here is a day with a falling barometer, overcast sky, 62 °F water and a moon between the quarters, the kind of day the planner otherwise likes, scored at different wind speeds:
| Wind | Wind sub-score | Overall score | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 mph | 85 | 85 | Excellent |
| 10 mph | 85 | 85 | Excellent |
| 12 mph | 60 | 80 | Excellent |
| 18 mph | 60 | 80 | Excellent |
| 19 mph | 30 | 44 | Poor |
| 25 mph | 30 | 44 | Poor |
| 40 mph | 30 | 44 | Poor |
Two things stand out. Between 10 and 18 mph the day still rates Excellent, because the other inputs are good and wind is only a fifth of the score. Then at 19 mph the rating drops straight to Poor and stays there. Without the cap, the 40 mph version of this day would have blended to 74 out of 100, an “Excellent” day by the numbers, which is exactly the setup ahead of a strong front. The planner used to rate it that way. Now it holds the score at 44 and shows this line instead:
Wind over 18 mph: this planner does not rate a day like this as a good fishing day. Check the local or marine forecast; a small boat, a kayak or wave-washed rocks are not the place for it.
Too windy for what?
There is no single wind speed that is safe for everyone. It depends on the craft, the water and the wind's direction.
- Kayaks and canoes are the most exposed. A wind that is pleasant on the bank can make paddling back upwind slow, tiring and, across open water, impossible. Wind and waves together are what capsize small craft. Many experienced paddlers set themselves a much lower limit than the planner's cap, especially on big water and in cold water.
- Small open boats handle more, but waves build quickly over a long stretch of open water. A wind blowing the length of a big lake raises far bigger waves than the same wind across a sheltered bay.
- Offshore winds, blowing from the land out to sea or across a lake away from your launch, are the most dangerous. The water near shore looks calm, and you drift away from it faster than you think.
- Shore and bank anglers have more margin, but strong wind still makes casting a hazard to anyone nearby, and waves on rocks and jetties are a real risk.
On the coast and big lakes, read the marine forecast, not just the local one. In the US, a small craft advisory from the National Weather Service is a clear signal to stay in. Plan to come in early if the wind rises during the day; forecasts often put the strongest wind in the afternoon.
Wind and the tide
On the coast, wind also moves the water. A strong onshore wind can hold the tide higher and longer than the table says, and wind blowing against a strong tidal current stacks up short, steep waves at inlets and river mouths. NOAA notes that even official tide predictions cannot include the effect of wind, rain and runoff. If you fish around the tide with our Tide Predictor, which is a fixed-cycle estimate, treat a windy day as one where the water may turn early, and give yourself more margin. Check the official tide table, and see how not to get cut off by the tide.
The lightning rule
Wind ahead of a front often comes with thunderstorms, and lightning is the one weather hazard that overrides everything else. Tick “thunder heard or storms forecast” in the planner and it gives no score; the rating reads “No score: thunder”, with the National Weather Service's advice:
The National Weather Service: “If you hear thunder, you are likely within striking distance of the storm.” “When Thunder Roars, Go Indoors!” Then “wait 30 minutes after the last lightning or thunder before going back outside.”
Anglers are especially exposed. Open water and flat shorelines leave you the tallest thing around, and most fishing rods are graphite, which conducts electricity. When you hear thunder, reel in, lay rods down and get off the water and into a building or a hard-topped vehicle. A tree, a tent or an open boat is not shelter. Waiting 30 minutes after the last thunder before going back out is part of the same rule.
Cold water raises the stakes
A capsize or a fall overboard is far more dangerous in cold water. In the first minutes, cold-water shock can make you gasp and breathe uncontrollably, which makes swimming hard and inhaling water easy. Spring is the risky season, when warm air tempts people out on water that is still cold. Wearing a life jacket, not just carrying one, is what keeps your head up through those first minutes.
A wind checklist before you launch
- Read the local and, on big water, the marine forecast for the whole time you will be out, including any advisories.
- Score the day in the planner, and treat a Poor rating with a wind hold as a day to fish from shore or not at all.
- Note the wind direction. Avoid offshore winds in small craft, and plan to fish with the wind helping you home.
- Wear a life jacket in any boat or kayak, and on rocks and jetties.
- Tell someone your plan and your return time, and carry a phone or radio in a waterproof bag.
- Come in when the wind rises or thunder is heard, whatever the fish are doing.
The planner's safety note says the same thing in fewer words: “This score is about the fish, not about whether it is safe to go out. Check the local or marine forecast before you leave and again on the water, wear a life jacket on a boat or on rocks, and come in early if the wind rises. “When Thunder Roars, Go Indoors!” (National Weather Service).”