FISHINGFIX
← The Journal
· The FishingFix Team

Best Bait for Catfish, Walleye and Pike: Baits, Rigs and Line

Catfish, walleye and pike are the fish people move on to once they have caught bass and panfish, and each asks for a different approach. Catfish feed largely by smell and taste, often at night. Walleye feed in low light near the bottom, with eyes built for dim water. Pike are fast ambush hunters with a mouth full of teeth. This guide gives what our Bait Selector suggests for each, the rig that goes with it, and the starting line strength from our Fishing Line Calculator.

At a glance

TargetLive or natural baitLures
CatfishCut bait, Chicken liver, Live shadStinkbait dip worm, Scented soft bait
WalleyeLeeches, Nightcrawlers, MinnowsJig and minnow, Crankbait, Bottom bouncer with spinner
PikeLarge shiners, Sucker minnowsSpoon, Large spinnerbait, Jerkbait, Swimbait

Starting line strengths from the line calculator: catfish 20 lb, walleye 8 lb, pike 30 lb.

Catfish: let the smell do the work

The selector's natural baits for catfish are cut bait, chicken liver and live shad. Its lure suggestions are a stinkbait dip worm and scented soft bait, both of which carry scent. Its tip: “Fish on the bottom after dark near current seams, holes, and channel edges.”

Catfish find food by smell and taste as much as by sight, which is why oily, strong-smelling baits work and why the bait does not need to move. Cut bait, meaning chunks of an oily fish such as shad, is a staple for channel and blue catfish. Chicken liver is a cheap, smelly bank-fishing classic, but soft; thread it on carefully or tie it in mesh so it stays on the cast. Live shad or other baitfish appeal to the bigger, more predatory catfish.

The rig. A sliding sinker rig is the standard: an egg or flat sinker slides on the main line above a swivel, then a short leader to the hook. A fish can pick up the bait and move off without feeling the sinker's weight. Use enough weight to hold bottom in the current and no more. Circle hooks suit catfish well: let the fish take the bait and tighten steadily, and the hook slides to the corner of the mouth, which also makes releasing fish easier.

Where and when. As the tip says, after dark near current seams, deep holes and channel edges. Catfish also feed by day, especially in stained water, but night is prime time in summer.

The calculator's 20 lb starting strength reflects heavy sinkers, snag-filled river bottoms and the size catfish can reach. Heavy cover and big rivers call for more.

Walleye: low light, near the bottom

For walleye the selector suggests leeches, nightcrawlers and minnows, and as lures: jig and minnow, crankbait and bottom bouncer with spinner. Its tip: “Target low-light periods and drag bait slowly across rocky points and breaks.”

Walleye have eyes adapted to dim light, so they feed hardest at dawn, dusk, at night and on overcast or windy days that cut the light. Through the middle of a bright day they often sit deeper or tight to cover.

  • Jig and minnow. A small jig head tipped with a minnow, worked along the bottom with short lifts and drops. Keep in touch with the bottom; most bites come as the jig falls.
  • Live bait rigs. A leech or nightcrawler on a long leader behind a sliding sinker, dragged slowly across rocky points and breaks, is a classic method.
  • Bottom bouncer with a spinner. A wire arm with a weight rides over the bottom while a spinner rig trails behind, tipped with a crawler. It is used when trolling slowly to cover water.
  • Crankbaits. Trolled or cast along shorelines and reefs in low light.

The 8 lb starting line is lighter than you might expect for the size of fish, because walleye bites are subtle and feel matters. Braid with a fluorocarbon leader is common for jigging; how to join braid to a leader covers the knot.

Pike: flash, speed and a wire leader

For pike the selector suggests large shiners and sucker minnows, and as lures: spoon, large spinnerbait, jerkbait and swimbait. Its tip: “Use a wire leader and burn flashy lures past weed edges to trigger reaction strikes.”

The wire leader is the most important part of that answer. Pike teeth cut monofilament, fluorocarbon and braid easily, whatever the pound test, and a fish that bites through the line swims off with a lure and hooks in its mouth. A wire or heavy leader between line and lure is standard practice. Pike strike out of weed beds at anything that flashes past, which is why spoons, spinnerbaits and jerkbaits worked fast past the weed edge trigger them. Big pike want big lures.

The 30 lb starting strength is effectively a braid figure: braid that strength is thin, casts heavy lures well and has the backbone to pull a pike out of weeds.

Handling pike. Unhook pike with long-nosed pliers or a dedicated hook remover, never fingers, and keep hands clear of the gill rakers as well as the teeth. Jaw spreaders and a rubber-mesh net make it easier on you and the fish. Support a big pike horizontally, under the belly, rather than hanging it by the jaw. If you plan to release it, keep it in the water as much as possible.

Bait rules for these species

Large shiners, sucker minnows, live shad and leeches are exactly the kind of baits that bait regulations cover. Some states allow only certain species of baitfish, require them to be bought from licensed dealers, or ban carrying live bait between waters, to stop invasive species and fish diseases spreading. Some waters require cut bait to come from fish caught in the same water. Bait is regulated: some waters ban live fish as bait, limit which species you may use, or bar moving bait or water between waters to stop invasive species and fish disease. Check the fishing regulations for the water before you buy or bring bait, and never release unused bait. Live bait rules covers what to check.

Safety, and eating what you keep

  • Night fishing for catfish and walleye: wear a life jacket in any boat or kayak, carry a headlamp and a backup light, use navigation lights, and tell someone where you are and when you will be back. Banks that are easy by day are treacherous in the dark.
  • Check the forecast. A planned night trip is not worth it with thunderstorms about; our Weather Fishing Planner gives no score when thunder is forecast, and that is the right call.
  • Large hooks and treble hooks in a thrashing fish are a real hazard. Control the fish before unhooking, and get medical care for a hook that is deep or near the eye.
  • Bigger, older predatory fish such as large catfish, walleye and pike often carry more contaminants. If you plan to eat your catch, check the state fish consumption advisory for that water first. Is it safe to eat the fish you catch? explains how to read one.
Get new guides by emailOccasional emails. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.