Is It Safe to Eat the Fish You Catch? Reading a Fish Consumption Advisory
For most anglers, eating some of what they catch is part of the point. Fish is a good food, and a fresh-caught walleye or panfish is hard to beat. The catch, in a different sense, is that fish from some waters carry contaminants that build up in the body over time, and the advice on how often to eat them varies from lake to lake and species to species. Every result from our Fish Weight Calculator carries the same reminder, quoting the US Environmental Protection Agency:
An estimate from a rule-of-thumb formula, not a weight: fish of the same length vary, and only a scale is exact. If you plan to keep and eat fish, check the advice for that water first. The EPA: “States, territories and Tribes issue advisories to protect people from potentially contaminated fish and shellfish caught in local waters.”
This guide explains what those advisories are, how to read one, and how to handle fish you keep so they are safe from the water to the plate. It does not give eating advice for any particular water. That comes only from the advisory itself.
Why advisories exist
Some chemicals in water and sediment are taken up by small organisms and passed up the food chain, building up in the fish that eat them. The best known are mercury and PCBs; some waters also have advisories for PFAS chemicals and others. These are not things you can see, smell or cook out of a fish. Mercury is in the flesh, so trimming does not remove it; PCBs and some other chemicals concentrate in fat, so trimming fat and skin reduces them but does not remove them.
The main concern is long-term exposure from eating contaminated fish often, not a single meal. That is why advisories are usually written as a number of meals per week or per month, rather than as “safe” or “unsafe”.
How an advisory is organized
State agencies, often the health department working with the fish and wildlife agency, publish advisories online and usually in the fishing regulations. Tribes and territories publish their own for their waters. A typical advisory is a table with:
- The water body: a named lake, river or stretch of river, and sometimes a statewide general advisory for waters not listed.
- The species. Predatory fish such as walleye, pike, bass and large catfish often have stricter advice than panfish from the same water.
- The size of the fish. Many advisories split a species by length, with stricter advice for longer fish, because older fish have had longer to accumulate contaminants.
- The recommended number of meals per week or month, sometimes with a separate column for women who are or may become pregnant and for children.
Why the size of your fish matters
Because advisories are often split by length, measure a fish you plan to keep. Size limits and advisories are separate things: a fish can be legal to keep and still fall into a stricter eating category. To give a sense of how quickly fish grow into the bigger bands, the calculator's length-only estimate for an 18 inch walleye is 2.16 lb, and for a 26 inch walleye 6.51 lb. With measured girths of 9 and 14 inches, the girth formula gives 1.82 lb and 6.37 lb. Those are estimates, and the advisory itself is read by length or species, not weight. The point is that the big fish you are proudest of is the one most worth checking. Many anglers keep smaller fish of a legal size for the table and release the big ones.
Who should take extra care
Advisories commonly carry stricter advice for people who are pregnant or may become pregnant, people who are breastfeeding, and young children, because developing nervous systems are most sensitive to mercury. If that applies to anyone you are cooking for, read that column of the advisory, not the general one. For personal health questions, ask a doctor.
How to find and read your advisory
- Search the state health department's or fish and wildlife agency's site for its fish consumption advisory. Our Fishing License Checker links to the official agency for ten states; the advisory is often linked from the same regulations.
- Find the specific water by name. If it is not listed, read the statewide general advice.
- Find the species and the length band for your fish.
- Note the meal frequency for you and for anyone more sensitive in your household.
- Check again each year. Advisories are updated as new sampling comes in.
The EPA publishes general national advice on choosing fish, and links to state, territorial and tribal advisories, at epa.gov.
From the water to the table
Fresh fish spoils quickly if it is not kept cold. Food safety is separate from contaminants, and just as important.
- Keep fish alive or cold. Either keep fish alive in a live well or on a stringer in cool water, or put them on ice straight away. Fish left in a warm bucket or in the sun spoil fast.
- Ice, not meltwater. Pack fish in plenty of ice in a cooler and drain meltwater, so the fish sit cold rather than soaking.
- Clean promptly and keep the cleaned fish refrigerated or frozen. Clean on a clean surface with a sharp fillet knife, cutting away from yourself, and wash hands and boards afterward.
- Cook thoroughly. The US Food and Drug Administration's advice is to cook fish to an internal temperature of 145 °F, until the flesh is opaque and separates easily with a fork.
- Follow the transport rules. Some states require fish to stay whole, or with a patch of skin left on, until you are home, so they can be identified and measured. Check before you fillet on the water.
Shellfish and saltwater
Shellfish such as clams, oysters and mussels have a different risk: they filter water and can carry bacteria and natural toxins from algal blooms. Recreational harvest areas open and close on short notice. Never harvest shellfish without checking the state's current shellfish closure map for that area, which is a separate list from the fish advisory.
Safety while you fish
Wear a life jacket in boats and kayaks and on rocks, leave the water when you hear thunder, and protect your skin from sun and hooks. A hook deep in skin or near the eye needs medical care.
In short
Eating your catch can be a healthy part of fishing. Check the advisory for the specific water, species and size; take extra care for children and anyone pregnant; keep fish cold from the moment you catch them; and cook them through. When in doubt about a big predator from a listed water, take a photo, log it in the Catch Log Tracker with its estimated weight, and let it go.